Dealer guide
Appraising trade-ins
Every trade-in has a retail value and a wholesale value. If the car fits your lot and the retail gross is worth the time, plan to retail it. If not, plan to wholesale it, and appraise to the wholesale number.
A good appraisal answers two questions: what is this car worth to you, and should you retail it or wholesale it. Follow the same steps every time so your numbers are consistent.
Before the walkaround
- Decode the VIN to confirm year, model, trim and options.
- Pull a vehicle history report: title brands, accidents, owners and odometer records.
- Check open recalls with NHTSA's lookup by VIN.[source]
- Ask about the loan. Get the lender and the payoff amount.
To value a car before you buy it, AutoVue's appraisal tool shows what it is worth in your market, how fast it should sell and what to pay.
The walkaround and test drive
- Exterior: panels, paint, glass, signs of repair.
- Interior: wear, smells, electronics, warning lights.
- Tires and brakes.
- A diagnostic scan for stored codes.
- A test drive: engine, transmission, steering, noises.
- Photos of anything that changes the value.
Find two values
Every trade-in has a retail value and a wholesale value.
- Retail: what you could sell it for on your lot, from comparable retail listings where your buyers shop.
- Wholesale: what it would bring at auction, from recent auction results and wholesale guides.
If the car fits your lot and the retail gross is worth the time, plan to retail it. If not, plan to wholesale it, and appraise to the wholesale number.
Build the offer
Retail offer = expected retail price − reconditioning − pack and fees − target gross.
Wholesale offer = expected wholesale price − transport − auction fees − your margin.
Example: you expect to retail a trade at $19,500. Reconditioning is $1,200, pack and fees are $500, and your target gross is $2,500. Your offer is $15,300.
Paperwork: odometer and title
Federal rules (49 CFR Part 580) require an odometer disclosure when ownership transfers, with exemptions in section 580.17. Two of them are age-based: vehicles from model year 2010 or earlier are exempt once transferred at least 10 years after January 1 of their model year, and vehicles from model year 2011 or later are exempt once transferred at least 20 years after that date.[source]
Title, lien release and payoff rules are set by each state. See title and registration rules by state.
Present the offer clearly
Show the customer how you reached the number: the comparables, the reconditioning the car needs, and the condition notes from the walkaround. A clear offer is easier to accept, and easier to defend if the customer shops it.
Sources
Sources checked November 17, 2026.
More guides
AutoVue · for dealers
See AutoVue in your market.
Every dealer at the auction sees the same run list. AutoVue shows you which cars on that list are worth buying for your market, updated daily with AI.
30-min demo for dealers